The excitement, the tension, the stakes; just a few components that will make the World Cup 2018 such exciting football to watch. With so much on the line, every goal will make a difference, with that making each penalty an opportunity to shift the odds and earn a potential win. But are those penalties down to sheer luck or is there more strategy involved?
JD Sports analysed 315 penalties, including career statistics from 22 penalty takers and 11 goalkeepers, taken by club and international players to see which players fared better and whose tactics rarely fail to score. The data looked at conversion rates, records, techniques and iconic goals scored on the grandest stage of them all to give a definitive list of the best and worst countries and players expected to be seen in this year’s World Cup.
The Best Penalty Takers
Best Penalty Takers: Career Stats
- Australia’s Mile Jedinak scored 100% of penalties in his career
- Messi and Ronaldo took and sucessfully scored 33% of all career penalties
Of the 22 players analysed, Australia’s Mile Jedinak is the only player to successfully convert every penalty taken in his career. Other players good career conversion rates (beating both Ronaldo and Messi even) include: Olivier Giroud, Marco Reus, Aaron Mooy, Zlatan Ibrahimović and Eden Hazard.
The 2018 Football Writers & PFA player of the year Mohamed Salah statistically has a better career conversion rate than Lionel Messi but slightly worse conversion rate than Cristiano Ronaldo. Lionel Messi has also missed the most penalties of all the players analysed in total.
Best Penalty Takers: Current Form
- The average conversion rate was 76%
- Australian players Mile Jedinak and Aaron Mooy have the highest conversion rates (100% and 90%)
- 76% of all penalties in our research were goals
We also looked at current form to show how consistent relevant players are ahead of the World Cup. We looked at the most recent 10 penalties taken by all 22 international takers. Interestingly, the average conversion rate of the 22 players was less than the average career conversion rate over career. This could suggest that goalkeepers are saving more penalties in recent years, or even that some of the top internationals are becoming less prolific from the spot when it comes to scoring penalties.
Of all, Jedinak is the most consistent penalty taker based on current form, scoring 10 out of 10 penalties taken with a perfect form record. Mooy has scored 9 out of 10 penalties, missing just one, proving to be one of the top penalty takers overall. Cristiano Ronaldo features again in the top and is bang in form at the moment, scoring 9 out of his last 10 penalties.
Cristiano Ronaldo, Marco Reus, Olivier Giroud and Aaron Mooy all have an excellent penalty conversion rate, with Mohamed Salah and Paul Pogba slightly lower. Neymar, Jamie Vardy, Zlatan Ibrahimović, Tim Cahill and Harry Kane all have a good conversion rate of all scoring 8 out of their last 10 penalties. Real Madrid and Spain Captain Sergio Ramos has a below average form conversion rate, having only taken 8 penalties in his career.
The Worst Penalty Takers
Worst Penalty Takers: Career Stats
- Antione Griezmann has the worst career conversion rate of all at 60%
- The average conversion rate was 81%
In his career Griezmann has taken 15 penalties scoring only 9 and missing 6. Similarly, Germany and Arsenal’s Mesut Özil had a below par average conversion.
The stats showed Lionel Messi isn’t as good at taking penalties as many people think compared to other international players, missing the most penalties.
It is important to note that players like Ronaldo, Messi, Ibrahimović, Hazard and Neymar have taken significantly more penalties overall than some of the other players listed. As a result, many football fans could argue that because of this these are the more reliable and proven penalty takers in highly pressurised situations.
Worst Penalty Takers: Current Form
- Thomas Müller is the worst penalty taker, with a conversion rate of 50%
Based on recent form; Germany and Bayern Munich’s, Thomas Müller has been unsuccessful in 5 of his last 10 penalties, with attempts either missing the target or being saved. The stats suggest that Lionel Messi and Mesut Özil are out of form recently, scoring only 6 of their last 10 penalties. Antoine Griezmann, Cesc Fàbregas and Luis Suárez have converted 7 of their last 10 penalties, but this was still below the current form average.
Best and Worst Goalkeepers
Back to top
Not just focusing on the top scorers, we also analysed the career statistics and current form of 11 international goalkeepers who are likely to be involved at the 2018 World Cup in Russia.
The Best Keepers: Career Stats
- Current Premier League goalkeepers have some of the worst career penalty save stats
- Australia’s Mathew Ryan has the best career save rate of 37%
- David de Gea came 5th of all with 27% of penalties saved
Statistically Brighton & Hove Albion and Australia’s Mathew Ryan performed best, saving 11 of the 30 penalties he has faced throughout his career. Germany and Bayern Munich’s Manuel Neuer is the second best shot stopper, saving 18 of his 52 penalties faced.
Manchester United’s David de Gea has saved over a quarter of all penalties faced throughout his career, not quite managing to beat some of the other nations teams, which may come as surprise to some fans.
Of all, just under a quarter of penalties were saved by the keepers in our career data with 76% of penalties being scored.
The Worst Keepers: Career Stats
- Hugo Lloris and Thibaut Courtois both had the lowest save rate at 16%
- England’s Jordan Pickford has saved just 17% of penalties
While both Hugo Lloris and Thibaut Courtois came last in the results, it should be noted Lloris has faced many more penalties than Courtois. In his career Lloris has faced 70 spot kicks saving just 11. In comparison Courtois has faced 31 saving just 5. Ederson also showed poor performance, only saving 5 of his total 18 penalties faced.
One of the worst performers is the man who many think will be England’s number 1 heading into Russia 2018: Jordan Pickford. Despite his excellent form for Everton this season, Pickford has faced 29 penalties and saved just 5 in his career.
The Best Keepers: Current Form
- Of 11 keepers assessed, the average save rate was 27%
- Brazil’s Ederson came top based on form with 50% saved
In our data, 4 goalkeepers have only saved 1 of their last 10 penalties: Thibaut Courtois, Rui Patricio, David de Gea and Fernando Muslera. Statistically these are the most out of form goalkeepers when it comes to saving penalties. As the average save rate was higher than the average career penalty save rate by 3%, suggesting that goalkeepers are currently saving slightly more penalties than they have done historically.
Brazil and Manchester City’s Ederson proved the most in form goalkeeper of all, having saved 5 of his last 10 penalties, despite a poorer performance career wise. Sergio Romero and Mathew Ryan are also displaying excellent form currently, saving 4 of the last 10 penalties they have faced.
Sweden’s Robin Olsen also has a solid penalty save rate based on current form. Ederson, Mathew Ryan, Jordan Pickford and Hugo Lloris on average are saving more penalties recently than they have throughout their careers, a welcome turnaround just in time for the World Cup we’re sure.
The Worst Keepers: Current Form
- David de Gea,Fernando Mulsera, Rui Patricio and Thibault Courtois all came bottom with 10% conversion rate on form
- England’s Jordan Pickford came 5th based on form
Although Hugo Lloris’ penalty save rate of his last 10 penalties is better than his career penalty save rate he still makes the bottom 5 overall. England’s Jordan Pickford shows average form currently, saving 6 of his last 10 penalties faced.
The bottom 4; Fernando Mulsera, Rui Patricio, Thibault Courtois and David de Gea only managed to save 1 of the last 10 penalties faced, joining for worst form goalkeepers.
The Best and Worst Countries for Penalty Takers
- Australia was the best performing country on penalties overall
- Spain were the worst country on career penalties with 3 players in the bottom 5 scorers
- Germany was the worst performing country based on form
- Spain was also in the bottom 5 countries on current performance
Surprisingly Australia were the best performing country based on penalty statistics. They have 2 penalty takers in the top 5 best performing players for career statistics and form statistics. Mile Jedinak has never missed a penalty in his career scoring all 14 penalties taken and Aaron Mooy has scored 9 of his 10 penalties taken. Tim Cahill also has a respectable 80% career penalty conversion rate, missing just one penalty. Great news for Socceroo’s fans.
Statistically based on career penalty conversion rate Spain are the worst performing international football team of all assessed. Cesc Fàbregas, Diego Costa and Sergio Ramos were all in the bottom 5 of career penalties. Spain also showed to be performing poorly looking at current form.
These three players occupy 3 spots in the worst 5 penalty takers, so it will be interesting to see who steps up in Russia if they win a penalty, or indeed in a penalty shootout situation. Based on career conversion rate Ramos should be Spain’s main penalty taker, despite taking fewer penalties than Costa and Fàbregas in his career.
The form stats don’t read well for German football fans either, as results in form show they have the two current worst penalty takers based on their conversion rate. This is surprising given Germany’s historical dominance and previous successes in penalty shootouts. Germany have a win percentage of 86% in penalty shootouts in major tournaments but will recent performance be more reflective of how this year’s tournament may go?
On the upside Germany do have a man bang in form from the penalty spot: Marco Reus. Reus has scored 9 of his last 10 penalties and possesses an impressive average form conversion rate of 90%. Based on the our findings, if he is in the starting line-up for the Germans, Reus should be their first choice penalty taker ahead of Özil and Muller. However, this may not be the case on the day.
The starts for both countries are surprising, given Germany and Spain’s previous successes in international tournament penalty shootouts.
Best & Worst Keepers: Country
- Australia has the best performing goalkeeper; Matthew Ryan at 37% saves
- Uruguay’s Fernando Muslera is the worst goalkeeper saving 15%
- France’s Hugo Lloris has the second worst career save rate of 16%
Statistically, Australia have the best goalkeeper in Mathew Ryan based on career penalty save rate; giving the Aussie’s good stats going into the 2018 World Cup. Germany have the second best goalkeeper in Manuel Neuer with a career penalty save rate of 35%, juxtaposing the overall performance of it’s penalty scorers.
Unfortunately for Uruguay, Fernando Muslera came last on save conversions with a low save rate. France’s Hugo Lloris has the second worst career save rate.
Brazil’s Ederson statistically is showing the best form heading into the 2018 World Cup in Russia, saving 5 of his last 10 penalties faced. Thibaut Courtois (Belgium,) Rui Patrício (Portugal,) David de Gea (Spain) and Fernando Muslera (Uruguay) are all out of form, with current save rates of 10% saving only 1 of their last 10 penalties faced.
